I agree with your statement (thanks for sharing) but to a point.
The MSF classes start you out on a 250 or 450 and you learn, practice and gain skill. (a class just like you would take to learn to drive an 18 wheeler) After passing the class you are qualified to ride pretty much any bike you want. Depending on how you do in the class you know and have a good idea what you can handle and if you should continue riding. But getting a little bike just because it's small doesn't fit with the principles and skill of riding. My MSF instructor rides a Goldwing and would bet his bike that it is easier to ride and manuever than the Buell 450 we trained on. He can do everything on the course that the 450 can and better. He gets gets irked when people constantly think that because his bike is so big it's hard to ride..Total myth.
My one classmate fell into the small bike theory and after only 3 weeks of riding she's selling her 883 Sportster for a Fat Boy. Glad I'm not part of the $$$ loss she is taking on her wrong decision.
Personally I'm very glad I bought the bike at the size I wanted and didn't settle for less. Honestly, the bike I own is NOT hard to ride or control, the extra brakes and power in fact give me more confidence in my ride.
I think too much emphasis is being put on the 5% of incompetent have-no-business on a bike riders getting a big bike than the majority of folks with the knowledge, skill and respect to be a good rider. If you are in the 5% don't get a 250, stay off bikes alltogether. The rest of you get what you know you want you'll be much happier. Insist on test drive from the stealer before you pay. If after the ride you don't feel comfortable, rethink your strategy.
The overall statistics are 75% of wrecks are from cagers and majority of the rest are from drunks on corners. The remaining 5% had no business on a bike in the first place. Don't see where the small bike theory is proven here.
Welcome any rebuttal, tell me something I don't know to change my mind on this subject if you have the info to back it up with. I would love to see a study on taking a group of newbie MSF graduates to a track and putting them on all sorts of bikes evaluating and measuring their skill on each bike of different sizes, types, etc... I bet you would be surprised at how well they would do on the bigger bikes compared to the smaller.
Just my 2 cents...
