Posted: Tue Nov 21, 2006 2:04 pm
Helmet selection guidelines:
1) DOT approved.
2) Good fit.
3) Suitability for your type of riding.
Everything else is secondary. Snell approval does net necessarilly mean one helmet is better than another. Bell helmets are not Snell approved because of the material from which they are constructed. Snell tests check the helmet for destruction under load. A well-engineered helmet will crush under load, absorbing energy that would otherwise transfer to your head. Testing should measure the reduction of force to which the helmet is subjected that is transmitted to the head. That is the true test of a helmet's engineering. That said, I did a faceplant at 160mph while wearing a Bell Star and walked away. I've seen other riders do a high speed faceplant with a Snell approved helmet lose their chins as the fiberglass shells abraided.
On the down side, Bells tend to be a little bigger and heavier because they use more foam to absorb impact instead of an easily crushable fiberglass shell. With use, your muscles will get used to the weight, and if you find the added aerodynamic drag a problem, slow down a few miles an hour.
Funny thing, Bells used to be about the most expensive on the market. Now, you can buy basic Bell helmets at some Walmarts. Volume marketing sure has brought the price down, too. Good helmets, good price, good value.
Whatever you do, avoid the cheap off-brands. The ones I looked at didn't deserve any sticker, so I suspect the DOT stickers are fake.
1) DOT approved.
2) Good fit.
3) Suitability for your type of riding.
Everything else is secondary. Snell approval does net necessarilly mean one helmet is better than another. Bell helmets are not Snell approved because of the material from which they are constructed. Snell tests check the helmet for destruction under load. A well-engineered helmet will crush under load, absorbing energy that would otherwise transfer to your head. Testing should measure the reduction of force to which the helmet is subjected that is transmitted to the head. That is the true test of a helmet's engineering. That said, I did a faceplant at 160mph while wearing a Bell Star and walked away. I've seen other riders do a high speed faceplant with a Snell approved helmet lose their chins as the fiberglass shells abraided.
On the down side, Bells tend to be a little bigger and heavier because they use more foam to absorb impact instead of an easily crushable fiberglass shell. With use, your muscles will get used to the weight, and if you find the added aerodynamic drag a problem, slow down a few miles an hour.
Funny thing, Bells used to be about the most expensive on the market. Now, you can buy basic Bell helmets at some Walmarts. Volume marketing sure has brought the price down, too. Good helmets, good price, good value.
Whatever you do, avoid the cheap off-brands. The ones I looked at didn't deserve any sticker, so I suspect the DOT stickers are fake.