Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2008 5:24 pm
My opinion as both a biker and a cager is that they might help in some situations and they certainly don't hurt anything. Any device that makes you even 5% more visible to other drivers is a good thing.
25 Years. 425 Million Readers. 54 years of Motorcycle Guides ∙ Reviews ∙ The friendliest motorcycle community on the internet!
https://www.totalmotorcycle.com/BBS/
They can hurt things: annoying drivers.Gunslinger wrote:My opinion as both a biker and a cager is that they might help in some situations and they certainly don't hurt anything. Any device that makes you even 5% more visible to other drivers is a good thing.
Well you have anecdotal evidence, because of your own annoyance. If it's drawing that much attention that you're annoyed, then it is making the rider more conspicuous. Although, I've got to ask why it's "annoying?"Skier wrote:They can hurt things: annoying drivers.Gunslinger wrote:My opinion as both a biker and a cager is that they might help in some situations and they certainly don't hurt anything. Any device that makes you even 5% more visible to other drivers is a good thing.
I know headlight modulators annoy drivers, myself included. I do not know modulators improve conspicuity. This is why I have not installed one on any of my motorcycles.
I'm all ears if there's studies about this but I haven't found a good one yet.
My anecdotal evidence spans more than my personal opinion on the flashing lights.NewGuy wrote:Well you have anecdotal evidence, because of your own annoyance. If it's drawing that much attention that you're annoyed, then it is making the rider more conspicuous. Although, I've got to ask why it's "annoying?"Skier wrote:They can hurt things: annoying drivers.Gunslinger wrote:My opinion as both a biker and a cager is that they might help in some situations and they certainly don't hurt anything. Any device that makes you even 5% more visible to other drivers is a good thing.
I know headlight modulators annoy drivers, myself included. I do not know modulators improve conspicuity. This is why I have not installed one on any of my motorcycles.
I'm all ears if there's studies about this but I haven't found a good one yet.
I'll to try to find something more than anecdotal evidence later.
SignalDynamics wrote:It has been proven that a flashing light is more visible than one steady on. That is one reason why the U.S. Federal DOT has legalized headlight modulators for safety. Its been reported that most motorcycle accidents involve front-end collisions. What's your safety worth?
My company is the leading manufacturer of headlight modules. I just wanted to know what positive or negative experiences or comments you have about these devices.
So you won't use one because it angers other drivers? Hey if a modulator sets someone off that easily they have bigger issues than you or I can fix. And I'd rather see a hundred bikes with these things on the road than one bike with those gawd awful 200 decibel pipes. Now those make me want to hurt somebody.Skier wrote:My anecdotal evidence spans more than my personal opinion on the flashing lights.NewGuy wrote:Well you have anecdotal evidence, because of your own annoyance. If it's drawing that much attention that you're annoyed, then it is making the rider more conspicuous. Although, I've got to ask why it's "annoying?"Skier wrote:They can hurt things: annoying drivers.Gunslinger wrote:My opinion as both a biker and a cager is that they might help in some situations and they certainly don't hurt anything. Any device that makes you even 5% more visible to other drivers is a good thing.
I know headlight modulators annoy drivers, myself included. I do not know modulators improve conspicuity. This is why I have not installed one on any of my motorcycles.
I'm all ears if there's studies about this but I haven't found a good one yet.
I'll to try to find something more than anecdotal evidence later.
The worst case scenario for not running a modulator is I'm just as visible as other motorcyclists out there.
Worst case for running a modulator is I anger a driver having a bad day and they try to run me off the road.
Easy decision.
Everyone has bad days and if I can prevent not be that last straw that breaks the camel's back, I'll take it.Gunslinger wrote: So you won't use one because it angers other drivers? Hey if a modulator sets someone off that easily they have bigger issues than you or I can fix. And I'd rather see a hundred bikes with these things on the road than one bike with those gawd awful 200 decibel pipes. Now those make me want to hurt somebody.
I don't need a study to tell me a flashing light is more conspicuous than one that doesn't.
Modulators don't flash the lights.Skier wrote:
My anecdotal evidence spans more than my personal opinion on the flashing lights.