Page 1 of 2

Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sat Oct 30, 2010 1:27 am
by hammeraxe
Hi, everyone!

We're a group of university students and in our business module we are to write a business plan to bring an innovative idea to the market.

The idea we're working on now is basically a motorcycle helmet with integrated blind spot sensors. They would be installed in the back left and back right of the helmet and warn the rider with two LEDs (for left and right blind spots respectively) lighting up in his field of view.

So would you use anything like this? Would you consider the issue of blind spots on motorcycles to be worth tackling?

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sat Oct 30, 2010 5:18 am
by Johnj
What's wrong with checking your six? I do all the time.

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sat Oct 30, 2010 5:24 am
by Wrider
I'd be afraid people would rely on it instead of their mirrors or checking. Plus daily driving in traffic would be a bit of a PITA because of your LEDs lighting up constantly.

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sat Oct 30, 2010 9:10 am
by fireguzzi
As long as the led's were easily ignorable and not too distracting I think it would be a good idea.

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sat Oct 30, 2010 11:37 am
by HYPERR
There is no such thing as a blind spot on a motorcycle.

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sat Oct 30, 2010 1:28 pm
by Gummiente
hammeraxe wrote:Hi, everyone!

We're a group of university students and in our business module we are to write a business plan to bring an innovative idea to the market.

The idea we're working on now is basically a motorcycle helmet with integrated blind spot sensors. They would be installed in the back left and back right of the helmet and warn the rider with two LEDs (for left and right blind spots respectively) lighting up in his field of view.

So would you use anything like this? Would you consider the issue of blind spots on motorcycles to be worth tackling?
Do any of you students actually ride a motorcycle?

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Sun Oct 31, 2010 3:00 am
by Lion_Lady
hammeraxe wrote:Hi, everyone!

We're a group of university students and in our business module we are to write a business plan to bring an innovative idea to the market.

The idea we're working on now is basically a motorcycle helmet with integrated blind spot sensors. They would be installed in the back left and back right of the helmet and warn the rider with two LEDs (for left and right blind spots respectively) lighting up in his field of view.

So would you use anything like this? Would you consider the issue of blind spots on motorcycles to be worth tackling?
You students should perhaps investigate innovation in a field you have more/some experience with. The last thing a rider needs is a flashing light in their field of vision. Riders quickly learn that there is no substitution for a head turn.

Such an indicator will probably be dangerous in low light conditions, or heavy traffic situations. How to distinguish a helmet light from a car's indicator? The discernment will require enough delay that it could mean the difference between avoidance and contact/crashing.

How would you mitigate liability to the company for an injured rider should they use this product and STILL be injured? That is perhaps the biggest reason that such cutesie innovations are rarely brought to market.

P

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Mon Nov 01, 2010 3:16 pm
by Grey Thumper
hammeraxe wrote:The idea we're working on now is basically a motorcycle helmet with integrated blind spot sensors. They would be installed in the back left and back right of the helmet and warn the rider with two LEDs (for left and right blind spots respectively) lighting up in his field of view.

So would you use anything like this? Would you consider the issue of blind spots on motorcycles to be worth tackling?
To quote Will Smith, awwww hell no.

Pointless and, IMHO, untrustworthy. Having small blindspot mirrors so you can confirm with your own eyes is a far simpler and more effective solution. Heck, I don't even completely trust my mirrors; mirrors only say "no". A quick headcheck is the only way to be sure.

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2010 6:35 am
by BuzZz
I hate all this driver/rider aid tech on vehicles these days. It takes already inattentive/poor driver and gives them an 'excuse' to pay even less attention or become a better operator.

Things on the road are scary enough, giving people a reason to care less about WTF they are doing out there is a bad, bad idea to me.

Re: Would you consider this useful?

Posted: Fri Nov 12, 2010 6:51 am
by profdan
I admire your attempt to find a viable motorcycle product; it's a daunting task if you're just part-way through your business studies.

However, I do agree with previous posts that a product for motorcycle blind spots would not be profitable because it wouldn't appeal to potential customers, motorcyclists.

If you or your fellow group members do not have much motorcycling experience, you might research the Hurt report, or more recent motorcycle accident statistics. These might help you better understand the safety issues we face. From that, you might come up with a more viable product for your business plan.

In any case, best wishes for a good project outcome.