Page 1 of 2

Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 4:47 am
by Trezorg
I'm ready to move on from my newbie bike, a suzuki savage. If money wasn't an object, I'd be getting a super glide without question, but money is short. So, I've narrowed the list down to Honda VTX1300C, Kawasaki Vulcan 900 Custom, V Star 1100 Custom and Suzuki Boulevard M50.

Does anyone have comments on these bikes either good or bad? Any well known problems with any of these? Which bike will provide the best bang for the buck under $5000? I'm ignorant of what's best for me in terms of shaft, belt or chain drive and air/water cooled so right now it's mainly the look of the bike. One thing I would prefer is not too loud pipes. Can I assume that stock pipes on these bikes would be about the quietest you'll find? In the spring I'll try riding a couple of each to get feel for them. If I know beforehand some of the likes and dislikes of others, it'll help me narrow my focus further.

I have done searches on these bikes on these forums and have gleaned some insight, but haven't seen real head to head matchups. The post below is from 3/14/2007, is it still valid?

"Honda is the highest quality and the most reliable of the metric bike bunch. Honda doesn't come out with much changes or new models every year like everybody else does, Honda improves their existing models by updating them every new year, yes Honda costs more but for that price you pay for better quality, Honda is the type of bike that you plan to own for 10 years, other brands are 2 or 3 year throw-away bikes. A Honda is a bike for a serious rider that plans to ride his bike almost every day, to commute, to take on long road trips, other bikes are designed for the casual rider that takes a short joy ride maybe one day a week. If you own a Honda no other metric biker will tell you that you made a mistake buying a Honda, HD guys will, but they don't know any better. Yamaha is moving up with the Star line of bikes, but Yamaha still has some quality control issues, Kawasaki and Suzuki have the reputation as the cheaper, generic bikes, and Suzuki has yet to earn any respect building a serious street bike. Buy what you want, what bike feels right, trust ur gut, make sure ur dealer supports you after the sale cause you will need his help."

So like the post above most posts are long in the tooth, can I get a fresh perspective?

In case it matters, my riding is daily about 30 miles with 2 or 3 100 mile plus rides a week. I don't know if that's considered a long ride or not.

Thanks in advance.

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Wed Dec 14, 2011 5:47 am
by madjak30
All are decent bikes and none are chain driven (provided you are looking at newer models...)

I would replace the V Star 1100 Custom with the V Star 950...but really any will make you happy...the biggest factor is parts availability...you are currently on a Suzuki, so I assume you can get parts (oil filters, air filters, etc...) decently...do you get a good feeling from the dealer?

That review is a little biased toward Honda...I would say all four are pretty close quality wise (Honda would get the nodd, but not by a huge margin in my opinion)...it will depend on what is comfortable for you...I found the Kawasaki quite comfortable, same as the Suzuki...but the Yamaha's were more classic cruiser than muscle cruiser...I haven't sat on a VTX Honda, so I couldn't tell you...I'm 5'11 with a 32" inseam (just to compare to yourself)...

I honestly don't think you could go wrong with any of the bikes...the Honda will be the performer of the group you mentioned and the rest will be very similar in performance (the V Star 1100 is an older motor...that's why I suggested the 950)...I would check insurance rates before you really make a decision...there can be big jumps by just going up a couple hundred CCs...

I envy you, shopping for a new bike is a pile of fun...enjoy it!!

Later.

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Thu Dec 15, 2011 7:40 pm
by blues2cruise
What madjak said...

Do you want lots of power or just moderate power? And....which one fits you best?

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Fri Dec 16, 2011 12:49 pm
by Trezorg
blues2cruise wrote:What madjak said...

Do you want lots of power or just moderate power? And....which one fits you best?
Lots of power isn't needed which is why I think 900-1100 is a good range. What are your likes and dislikes about your Vulcan?

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Fri Dec 16, 2011 2:19 pm
by blues2cruise
Trezorg wrote:
blues2cruise wrote:What madjak said...

Do you want lots of power or just moderate power? And....which one fits you best?
Lots of power isn't needed which is why I think 900-1100 is a good range. What are your likes and dislikes about your Vulcan?
My only dislike about the Vulcan is that the clutch lever is hard to pull....and..it is a bit of a long reach....I solved the problem by installing an EZ clutch...I also had the windshield cut down to a proper size. Other than that the bike is great.

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2012 8:35 pm
by dablade
Congrats on your (future) new bike! My own personal likes are diverse, but I have owned a Honda VTX 1300, and I thought it was a pig. It sure was pretty to look at, though.
In order to offer any constructive advice, what is your price range? Are you buying new, or used? Where, and what kind of riding do you do? Do you commute to work, etc on your bike? Do you ride with a passenger at all? Do you require any on- board storage?

Regards, Perry

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:31 am
by Trezorg
dablade wrote:Congrats on your (future) new bike! My own personal likes are diverse, but I have owned a Honda VTX 1300, and I thought it was a pig. It sure was pretty to look at, though.
In order to offer any constructive advice, what is your price range? Are you buying new, or used? Where, and what kind of riding do you do? Do you commute to work, etc on your bike? Do you ride with a passenger at all? Do you require any on- board storage?

Regards, Perry

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:40 am
by Trezorg
Hey! What happened to the post I just posted!!!!

Oh well, here's the response again.

Please define pig. Trouble getting up to speed? Mechanical problems?

I'll be going used for under $5k. I ride when the weather permits, to work, to play, whatever. Sledom with a passenger and minimal storage required. I'm looking at the midrange sizes as I'm getting the opinion that the larger bikes would be too bulky and just not as much fun as the bike I currently have. In the spring I'll go to a dealer that will let me test ride until my heart's content. Then I'll know what's best for me. Until then, I'm interested in people's opinion of the bikes I listed above.

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2012 6:20 pm
by blues2cruise
Keep your eyes open for demo days. Lots of manufacturers have demo days and go around to different dealers.

Also...find out where the cost of insurance goes up..that may be a factor.

Re: Time to get a newer bike

Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2012 12:22 pm
by Johnj
A pig is any of the animals in the genus Sus, within the Suidae family of even-toed ungulates. Pigs include the domestic pig, its ancestor the wild boar, and several other wild relatives. Pigs are omnivores and are highly social and intelligent animals.